The Rutherford

Bars in Midtown West often cater to the after-work crowd, but few sit as conveniently near Penn Station as The Rutherford. The stretch of W 33rd Street between 7th and 8th Avenues has long been a thoroughfare for commuters and theatergoers, making it a practical stop for those passing through. This area’s mix of office towers and pre-war buildings gives it a rhythm that shifts from daytime hustle to evening unwind, with bars playing a quiet but steady role in that transition.

New York’s bar scene doesn’t always require a gimmick—sometimes proximity and consistency matter more. A block from Madison Square Garden and a short walk from Herald Square, the location alone ensures a rotating cast of locals, tourists, and business travelers. While the neighborhood has no shortage of options, the ones that endure tend to be those that don’t overpromise. Directions are simple: it’s on the north side of the street, where the gridlock of 33rd meets the pulse of the city.

Questions about hours or private events are best answered directly, so call (212) 629-7070 for the latest details. As with most Manhattan bars, the best approach is to check ahead if you’re planning around a game or show—timing can make all the difference. For a precise route, the map lays out the shortest path from the nearest subway stops.