Super Nice Pizza

The Upper West Side has long been a neighborhood where pizza joints come and go, but a few stick around by keeping things simple. Super Nice Pizza fits that mold, offering the kind of no-frills service that locals rely on when the craving hits. Dinner crowds and solo diners tend to gravitate here, likely because the pace matches the city’s rhythm—quick enough to feel efficient, but not so rushed that you’re shuffling out the door before the last slice is finished.

On Amsterdam Avenue near 107th Street, the spot handles both takeout and dine-in without the usual fanfare. Beer and cocktails make the menu, which means it’s easy to pair a slice with something stronger than soda if that’s the mood. For those who need it, an assistive hearing loop is available, a detail that’s more common in theaters than pizzerias. Questions about orders or hours? The number to call is (347) 793-8338—no automated menus, just the straightforward kind of exchange that keeps regulars coming back.

The address, 975 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10025, places it within walking distance of both the 1 train and the park, making it a practical stop after a long day. Directions are best pulled up via this map link, especially if you’re coming from farther uptown. It’s the kind of place that doesn’t need a hard sell—just a reliable slice and a seat when you need one.