Mithaiwala

Across the city’s food map, Indian restaurants populate the outer edges of the core dining zones. They trade foot-traffic flash for steady local followings. Mithaiwala sits south of Chelsea’s galleries, where the sidewalks hum with casual footwork and the air carries the scent of spices from nearby kitchens.

At 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, Mithaiwala offers a modest storefront amidst the neighborhood’s grit and glitter. The menu balances comfort food with traditional vegetarian dishes—think dal makhani, chana masala, and mango lassi—while lunch turns early and dinner spills into the evening. Casual plates arrive quickly, and dessert arrives even faster. Families queue for a booth; the hum of conversation drowns out the street noise.

A quick call lands your table without a formal reservation. Smile at the host, state your party size, and the third chair usually appears. They don’t take bookings but they won’t turn you away. A flick of the wrist on the phone secures a space, no apps required.

Find directions on the map before you leave the subway: https://www.google.com/maps/place?ftid=0x89c259c85074d9a9:0xc517de1fa00ce497