Made In New York Pizza

The Upper West Side gets another pizza option. Made In New York Pizza fits right into the neighborhood’s mix of quick bites and sit-down spots, offering both takeout and dine-in without the frills. It’s the kind of place where solo diners grab a slice between errands or where small groups linger over comfort food. Lunch and dinner crowds keep the rhythm steady, but there’s no pretension—just pizza by the slice or whole pies, depending on the hunger level.

Finding it is simple: walk along Broadway until you hit 2563, between 96th and 97th Streets. The address sits in a stretch where foot traffic blends residents with Columbia students and theater-goers heading uptown. Curbside pickup makes it easy for those passing through in a hurry, while the option to stay and eat caters to anyone wanting a pause. No need to plan ahead—this isn’t the type of spot that demands reservations or a lengthy wait.

Call (917) 261-4660 if you’d rather place an order by phone, though walking in works just as well. The menu leans into what pizza places do best: quick, unfussy meals that don’t require a second thought. Whether it’s a midday slice or a late dinner, the focus stays on the basics—no gimmicks, just a straightforward list of offerings that match the neighborhood’s pace.

For directions or to double-check the location, pull up the map before heading out. It’s one of those places that doesn’t need a hard sell—just a reliable spot when you’re craving pizza and don’t want to overthink it.