M & Pizza

M & Pizza serves New York-style pies right where the theater district hums. Walk into 625 9th Avenue and you’ll spot the modest red-brick storefront tucked between the tall buildings. Inside, expect classic slices and whole pies that move faster than the foot traffic outside.

The menu keeps things simple but satisfying: coffee by the cup, cookie desserts, hearty comfort food, and quick grab-and-go bites. Families pop in because kids aren’t fussy here, solo diners swing by midday, and late-night crowds line up after shows. Catering trays for larger groups also slide out the kitchen door without fanfare.

Call (212) 837-1143 to place an order, then swing south across Times Square if you’re on foot. Find the spot on the map here: directions.