Little Italy Pizza

Pizza in Manhattan often feels like a trade-off—speed versus quality, tradition versus convenience. Little Italy Pizza at 1367 Broadway, New York, NY 10018, seems to sidestep that dilemma entirely. The spot sits where Midtown’s hustle meets the lingering echoes of old-school Italian-American takeout joints, a stretch of sidewalk where tourists and office workers cross paths without much ceremony.

What sets them apart isn’t just the casual seating or the fact that they serve alcohol alongside late-night slices. It’s the rhythm of the place: lunch crowds thinning into solo diners hunched over quick bites, then filling up again when dinner service kicks in. They keep the menu simple—comfort food that doesn’t demand a reservation or a long sit-down. If you’re passing through the Theater District and need something fast without sacrificing the basics, this corner of Broadway delivers.

Directions are straightforward enough; the map will get you there. For a slice or a beer, call (646) 448-4269. The neighborhood doesn’t slow down after dark, and neither does this kitchen.