Honey Pie Pizza

Pizza joints in Manhattan tend to fall into two camps: the no-frills slice shops for a quick bite and the sit-down spots where you can linger over a pie. Honey Pie Pizza fits somewhere in between, offering both takeout efficiency and a place to settle in for lunch or dinner. The West 26th Street location puts it within easy reach of Chelsea’s mix of galleries, offices, and residential blocks—ideal for solo diners grabbing a fast meal or groups splitting a few pies with drinks. Alcohol is on the menu, which isn’t always a given at neighborhood pizzerias, and the assistive hearing loop suggests they’ve thought about accessibility beyond the basics.

Quick service is a highlight here, whether you’re popping in for a solo meal or picking up an order to go. The spot leans into comfort food territory, which makes sense given the name—though don’t expect a dessert-heavy menu. Lunch and dinner crowds both filter through, with the kind of steady traffic that suggests it’s a regular stop for locals rather than just a tourist draw. No need to plan ahead for a table, but the option to dine in means you can treat it like a proper meal if you’re not in a rush.

Finding it is straightforward: just head to 601 W 26th St between 11th and 12th Avenues. Questions about the menu or hours? Call 212-675-7437 for the quickest answer. For turn-by-turn directions, the map listing has you covered.