Fire Island Sup and WaterSports

Right on Ocean Beach, Fire Island Sup and WaterSports turns the bay into a playground. They outfit visitors with everything needed to ride the waves all season long—stand-up paddleboards, kayaks, surf skis, snorkeling gear, fishing rods, and even wetsuits. It’s the kind of spot where morning light hits the water just right, making the rentals feel like an extension of the day’s plans rather than a detour.

The shop sits at At FLYNNS, 9 Cayuga St, tucked into a stretch of Ocean Beach where backyards meet the bay. Anyone pulling up the curb can grab gear and be on the water within minutes, no detours required. The address is simple to remember, but the quickest way to find it is still the map.

They can field questions or lock in rentals by calling (631) 326-7926. A quick check of the directions puts you on site before the tide changes.