DartFellas

Dart shops aren’t common in the city, which makes finding one that stocks everything from casual boards to tournament-grade gear a quiet win. DartFellas fills that gap for players who prefer a physical store over endless online scrolling. The selection here covers the essentials—steel-tip darts, soft-tip sets, replacement flights, shafts, and even scorekeeping accessories—without the noise of a big-box sports aisle.

Their storefront sits at 347 West 36th Street, a stretch of Midtown where small businesses share the sidewalk with garment suppliers and lunch counters. The area hums with weekday energy but quiets down after dark, offering a low-key stop for anyone assembling a home setup or prepping for league night. Parking can be tight, so most visitors arrive on foot or by subway.

Calls to (929) 249-0644 can save a trip if you’re hunting for a specific brand or weight, though browsing in person often turns up unexpected finds. They keep regular hours, but it’s wise to ring ahead if you’re planning a long session—some items sell out faster than others, especially around tournament season.

For directions, pull up the map and plot a route that avoids the busiest blocks. The walk from Penn Station is under ten minutes, making it an easy detour between errands or before heading home.