Craving the freshest seafood on the Upper West Side? You’re in luck—this vibrant neighborhood boasts some of the city’s best spots for ocean-to-table delights. From cozy oyster bars to elegant sushi counters, we’ve handpicked the top seafood destinations that locals love. Whether you’re after buttery lobster rolls or expertly seared scallops, our curated list ensures every bite is unforgettable. Get ready to savor the catch of the day, right in the heart of NYC.
From sushi bars to raw oyster spots, this curated list showcases the Upper West Side’s diverse seafood scene. Readers will find expert recommendations tailored to every craving, ensuring a satisfying meal. Ready to dive in? Your next favorite bite awaits.
-
1. Aqua Boil
⭐ 4.7/5 (2,876 reviews)
Warm golden light spills across polished wood tables as the hum of lively conversation blends with the sizzle of garlic butter hitting hot skillets. At Aqua Boil, the Upper West Side’s go-to seafood boil spot, the air carries the briny scent of Cajun-spiced shrimp and buttery lobster, steaming in custom seasoned broths. Crisp white paper lines tables ready for crack-and-peel feasts, while...
Address: 750 9th Ave New York, NY 10019
-
2. Atlantic Grill
⭐ 4.5/5 (1,046 reviews)
For over three decades, Atlantic Grill has been a beloved seafood destination on the Upper West Side, serving up fresh, sustainably sourced seafood in a warm, inviting atmosphere. Known for its legendary oysters, succulent lobster rolls, and expertly grilled fish, this iconic spot blends classic New York charm with coastal flavors. The menu features seasonal catches, expertly prepared with simple...
Address: 50 W 65th St At Lincoln Center Plaza New York, NY 10023
-
3. Crave Fishbar Upper West Side | Raw Bar & Seafood restaurant
⭐ 4.5/5 (818 reviews)
Fresh oysters glisten on ice, their briny kiss awakening the palate. At this Upper West Side seafood haven, the raw bar hums with energy—laughing crowds savoring buttery lobster rolls, crispy fish tacos, and chilled crudo. The scent of lemon and sea salt lingers as plates of golden-crusted whole fish arrive, paired with chilled rosé. Whether perched at the sleek marble bar or tucked into a cozy...
Address: 428 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024
-
4. Luke's Lobster Upper West Side
⭐ 4.4/5 (903 reviews)
**Fresh, sustainable lobster rolls land on the Upper West Side at this beloved seafood shack, where buttery, toasted brioche buns cradle sweet, chilled Maine lobster. Unlike typical spots, they source directly from fisherman-owned co-ops, ensuring peak freshness and ethical practices. Pair your roll with a crisp local craft beer or a zesty lemonade, then dig into their famous truffle-lobster mac...
Address: 426 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024
-
Advertise on Manhattan-NYC.com
Manhattan-NYC.com helps visitors discover local restaurants, services, shops, attractions, and neighborhood businesses across Manhattan.
This sponsored area can place your business in front of readers browsing related Manhattan guides and blog content.
Contact us to request advertising options.
-
5. The Shell Seafood Kitchen & Bar
⭐ 4.8/5 (250 reviews)
Seafood lovers and Upper West Side locals flock to this vibrant spot for its fresh, expertly prepared dishes. The lively bar scene draws crowds craving oysters, lobster rolls, and crisp white wines, while the kitchen’s signature seafood towers and wood-grilled fish keep regulars coming back. With a sleek, modern setting and a menu bursting with coastal flavors, it’s the go-to for date nights,...
Address: 635 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10025
-
6. El Fish Marisqueria
⭐ 4.6/5 (284 reviews)
Fresh, vibrant seafood takes center stage at this Upper West Side favorite, where locals rave about the ceviche’s bright citrus kick and the buttery lobster rolls piled high. The garlic-sizzled shrimp and crispy whole fried fish draw crowds, while the daily oyster selection—briny, sweet, and served on ice—keeps regulars coming back. A lively spot with a no-frills vibe, it’s perfect for those...
Address: 155 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10023
-
7. The Mermaid Inn Upper West Side
⭐ 4.4/5 (161 reviews)
**Savor the catch of the day at this charming Upper West Side seafood haven, where fresh oysters, buttery lobster rolls, and crisp white wine set the scene for an unforgettable meal. Warm wood accents and soft candlelight create a cozy yet refined atmosphere, perfect for date nights or lively gatherings. The menu shines with locally sourced fish, expertly prepared with bold flavors and seasonal...
Address: 335 Columbus Ave New York, NY 10023