Craving the perfect slice in NYC’s Upper West Side? You’re in the right place. This neighborhood delivers legendary pizza, from classic New York-style to artisanal creations. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, we’ve handpicked the best spots where crispy crusts, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese reign supreme. Get ready to indulge in the ultimate pizza crawl—no tourist traps, just pure, delicious authenticity. Let’s dig in!
From classic Neapolitan slices to bold, inventive toppings, this list covers every craving. Readers will find insider tips, must-try spots, and local favorites to elevate their pizza journey. Ready to dig in? Your perfect slice awaits just around the corner.
-
1. Mama's TOO! Upper West Side
⭐ 4.2/5 (2,614 reviews)
Warm golden light spills over rustic wooden tables, casting a cozy glow on the lively Upper West Side crowd. The air hums with laughter and the rich aroma of wood-fired pizza, fresh basil, and garlic. Exposed brick walls frame the open kitchen, where chefs toss dough with practiced ease. A curated playlist of classic rock and soul sets the mood, blending seamlessly with the clink of glasses and...
Address: 2750 Broadway New York, NY 10025
-
2. Made In New York Pizza
⭐ 4.6/5 (1,214 reviews)
Savor the legendary flavors of authentic New York pizza on the Upper West Side. Made In New York Pizza crafts hand-tossed pies with crispy, chewy crusts, tangy tomato sauce, and premium toppings. For over 30 years, this iconic spot has perfected the art of coal-fired perfection, drawing locals and visitors alike. The aroma of bubbling mozzarella and fresh basil fills the air, while the crackling...
Address: 421 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024
-
3. Patsy's Pizzeria
⭐ 4.3/5 (1,622 reviews)
The warm glow of the oven, the rich aroma of garlic and basil, and the first crisp bite of a perfectly charred slice—this is the magic of classic New York pizza. At this beloved Upper West Side spot, every visit feels like a reunion with an old friend. The thin, foldable crust crackles under your fingers, while the tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella deliver that unmistakable NYC flavor....
Address: 61 W 74th St New York, NY 10023
-
4. Sal and Carmine Pizza
⭐ 4.4/5 (738 reviews)
Craving authentic New York-style pizza on the Upper West Side? Sal and Carmine Pizza delivers the perfect slice—crispy yet chewy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella, all baked in a classic coal-fired oven. Their signature square slices, cut from a massive 24-inch pie, offer a nostalgic taste of old-school NYC pizzerias. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or dining in, the bold...
Address: 2671 Broadway New York, NY 10025
-
Advertise on Manhattan-NYC.com
Manhattan-NYC.com helps visitors discover local restaurants, services, shops, attractions, and neighborhood businesses across Manhattan.
This sponsored area can place your business in front of readers browsing related Manhattan guides and blog content.
Contact us to request advertising options.
-
5. Song’e Napule Upper West
⭐ 4.7/5 (458 reviews)
Neapolitan pizza lovers and Upper West Side locals flock to Song’e Napule for its authentic wood-fired pies, crafted with imported Italian ingredients. The cozy, rustic vibe—complete with a blistering brick oven and the scent of charred crust—draws crowds craving true Napoli flavors. Regulars rave about the chewy, leopard-spotted dough and fresh buffalo mozzarella, while date-night diners savor...
Address: 464 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024
-
6. Parla
⭐ 4.6/5 (389 reviews)
**Savor the Upper West Side’s favorite wood-fired pies at Parla, where crispy Neapolitan crusts meet bold, locally sourced toppings. Regulars rave about the spicy *Diavola* with fiery calabrian chili and the creamy *Burrata e Prosciutto*, drizzled with honey. Pair your slice with a glass of Italian wine or a craft cocktail—perfect for a cozy night out. The warm, rustic vibe and open kitchen make...
Address: 320 Columbus Ave New York, NY 10023
-
7. Mimi's Pizza (Broadway)
⭐ 4.8/5 (263 reviews)
Warm, golden crusts crackle under the glow of neon lights as the rich aroma of garlic and melted mozzarella fills the air. Mimi’s Pizza on Broadway delivers classic New York slices with a cozy, old-school vibe—think red-checkered tablecloths, steaming Sicilian pies, and crispy thin-crust options. Perfect for late-night bites or family dinners, this Upper West Side staple serves up generous...
Address: 2393 Broadway New York, NY 10024
-
8. Double Pie Pizza - Artisanal NY Pizza
⭐ 4.8/5 (214 reviews)
Friendly staff greet you with a smile, crafting artisanal NY pizza with hand-tossed dough and fresh toppings. The cozy Upper West Side spot buzzes with warmth, offering crispy, cheesy slices and specialty pies. Quick service, generous portions, and a welcoming vibe make every visit memorable. Perfect for a casual bite or a family feast.
Address: 924 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10025
-
Advertise on Manhattan-NYC.com
Manhattan-NYC.com helps visitors discover local restaurants, services, shops, attractions, and neighborhood businesses across Manhattan.
This sponsored area can place your business in front of readers browsing related Manhattan guides and blog content.
Contact us to request advertising options.
-
9. Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side
⭐ 4.5/5 (270 reviews)
Craving authentic NYC pizza on the Upper West Side? Two Boots Pizza delivers bold Cajun-Italian flavors with hand-tossed crusts, zesty marinara, and premium toppings. Their coal-fired ovens create that perfect crispy-yet-chewy bite, while creative slices like the "Bayou Beast" (spicy andouille sausage) and classic Margherita satisfy every craving. A local favorite for decades, this spot blends...
Address: 70 W 71st St New York, NY 10023
-
10. Village Square Pizza - Upper West Side
⭐ 4.6/5 (124 reviews)
**Savor the crisp, wood-fired crust of Village Square Pizza’s legendary Upper West Side slices, where tangy tomato sauce meets creamy mozzarella and fresh basil. This beloved NYC pizzeria crafts hand-tossed pies with locally sourced ingredients, delivering that perfect chewy-yet-crisp bite. Whether you crave classic Margherita or loaded meat lover’s, their coal-fired oven ensures smoky depth in...
Address: 2479 Broadway New York, NY 10025